I’d spent most of my life wanting/expecting to bestow on my kids names so Irish in origin that you’d assume they’d bust out in a jig at a moment’s notice.
My name literally means “Ireland.” Because I grew up so strongly ensconced in Irish-American culture, I wore this as a badge of immense pride. It wasn’t just that I come from an Irish lineage, but I am in fact so Irish that my name is the geographical spot of Irish people. Or something. When I look at our family tree – which I luckily have, and it dates back to the early 1800s - I am the only Erin. Which doesn’t shock Irish people since I think most Irish folks, and it’s certainly true in my family, have many more “Mary Something-Or-Others” than Erin’s. My aunt Peg was Mary Margaret, for example.
My love of my heritage has as much to do with my love for my family, as it does for Ireland. And that’s generally the point. So it was always something I assumed I’d pass along to my own child, neatly symbolized in a name like “Mary Katherine” or “Seamus.”
My husband, however, wasn’t exactly on board. While his mom shares my love for all-things-Irish, and a celebration does not pass by without she and I buying each other Celtic-themed items, Scott has no particular connection to being Irish. Every name I proposed was summarily shot down. Or made fun of. Or met with him mockingly humming fiddle music.
There was very little chance my daughter was going to be able to bear the same puffy pride I did, and I let that go. It’s what you do in a marriage sometimes, especially when there are greater battles to fight in life, and this is one you’d sooner sit out.
But battle we did on names in general. Everything I suggested was shot down. And he will argue with me, I know, because it’s what he does, but the man did not suggest one single alternative, whether it be for a first or middle name. If he did and I missed it, Scott, my love, I welcome the rebuttal in the comments.
I’ll wait.
And so I spun my wheels and remembered one night, long before we were pregnant, or even moved to Beverly, when we were watching The West Wing. You have to understand the passion for which we love this show, Scott especially. My entire family, too. Once I came home to find my dad playing Jeff Buckley’s version of “Hallelujah” on his 12-string after hearing it on an episode of the show. My sister, Kate, is equally as ravenous for the show.
“What about ‘Abigail’ if we ever have a girl,” I said.
“Hmmm,” he said. “OK. I like that.”
Naming our daughter after a television character, even one as amazing as Abigail Bartlett, kind of haunted me. There is a family story that my name wasn’t actually a nod to our Irish heritage but a nod to The Waltons, a favorite TV show of my mother’s. I didn’t want to go down that route, even if it was a fallacy, but here we were. So I did some research on Abigails, and found another first lady who would fit the bill, and settle my soul a bit:
Abigail Adams.
And it was this excerpt from her March 1776 letter to her husband John and the Continental Congress, stating that they, “…remember the ladies, and be more generous and favorable to them than your ancestors. Do not put such unlimited power into the hands of the Husbands. Remember all Men would be tyrants if they could. If particular care and attention is not paid to the Ladies we are determined to foment a Rebellion, and will not hold ourselves bound by any Laws in which we have no voice, or Representation.”
Well heck yes then. I fully expect my daughter to form a rebellion if needed.
And so “Grace.”
It’s a popular name these days, and so I initially shied away from it. But in thinking about the women we were naming our daughter after, the sort of women we’d hope to inspire her to follow, fiction or not, one other woman came into my mind.
Sr. Grace Henneberry.
Sr. Grace is a Dominican sister who was a teacher at my high school in the 1990s. I probably don’t have the eloquence to describe the sort of person Sr. Grace is, but there is one undeniable fact about her: she seeks out the good in every person she encounters, and even more importantly, she makes people feel good about themselves. Can you imagine being that way? Being the sort of person who, without exception, makes every single person she encounters feel loved, acknowledged and cared for? It’s not just that she’s kind, because she is, but it’s something more deliberate, more purposeful.
Anyone can be kind. It’s another person altogether who can so selflessly make it so that she puts others and their feelings first.
You just feel better being in her presence, and for as much as I look forward to the revolutions Abigail will no doubt lead, more than anything for her we wish that she is the sort of woman who cherishes and takes sacred the feelings of those around her and looks to empower those with whom she encounters with the sort of peace and joy that Sr. Grace does for so many.
So her name doesn’t scream wool sweaters or tri-color flags, but that doesn’t really matter. Besides, there’s no reason why she still can’t learn to jig.











Your daughter’s name is lovely and it’s great that it means something to you — helpful in about the 2nd or 3rd grade when they invariably come home with an assignment to write about why they’re named what they are and if it “means” anything. (Embarrassing when your daughter’s name came of reading “trashy romance novels” gobbled up while pregnant.
Anyway, re: Irish names –my daughter’s best friend comes from a huge Irish family whose kids’ names are: Seamus, Brendan, Declan, Maura, Tadgh, and Liam. Poor Tadgh — always having to correct pronunciation and spelling his name, which we always bastardize to sounding like “Tige” anyway.
Nice story and a great name. I’m not going to lie though, Abigail kind of feels like an Irish name to me, even if it is not
I’m very Irish, as well. My mom was an O’Hara and she had to be talked down from naming me “Scarlett O’Hara…” and then “Tara O’Hara…”. My husband also had little appreciation for the beautiful, traditional Irish names. I LOVE the name Erin. I also love The West Wing (I have heard Bravo is starting them again in April! Right in time for Maternity Leave for me!)
You can always remind Abigail, “If you’re lucky enough to be Irish, you’re lucky enough.”
It’s a strong and pretty name, with a charming nickname for the small years. I think it’s a fine choice. And Grace is popular for a reason.
I have made lists of names forever, girl names. I had lots of favorites. When we found out we were having a boy, it was kind of a relief as there was only one name we agreed on: Archer.
We’re in trouble if we have a second boy though. We could call him Archer2 maybe?
Abigail is a beautiful name, and I have no doubt that your Abigail will embody the name with her own personality and joie de vivre.
Also, naming your kid after a tv show character isn’t too shabby (ahem Lindsey from Freaks and Geeks, albeit spelled differently)!
Had EXACTLY the same problem with my husband, with both kids. He shot down every name I came up with and never thought up single girl’s name on his own — which was unfortunate because we ended up having two girls. We were a week away from the birth of daughter #2 and were still stuck with the backup name from daughter #1, which I was pretty of bummed about. Then I suddenly pulled out a dark-horse name from early in the pregnancy and he actually admitted to liking it. And that was that. Just under the wire.
It’s funny, I am super Irish-American as well, my parents and family were always involved with the NJ Irish American Association when we were growing up, etc., but my kids sound like they are straight out of Italy. My favorite Irish name is Aisling (AshLEEN), which means ‘vision, or dream’ and I love it but I just can’t see naming a baby that when it would just be mispronounced all of her midwestern life. I love Abigail’s name, it’s beautiful and strong and classic.
As a fellow Erin (and one that was named after Erin on the Waltons) I don’t see any shame in having a name that has television roots. I think Abagail Grace is a beautiful name.
Congrats from a long-time reader/lurker.
Are we related?? I also come from a family that identifies itself as very Irish, and I have always been happy with my name. We had the same problem when trying to figure out a name, my husband was quite the serial dater in high school, and it seemed every name I mentioned was an old girlfriend. I think we finally agreed on a girl’s name 3 days before our daughter was born, thank goodness we didn’t have a boy, we never found a name we both liked. I adore the name Abigail, very strong but with a cute nickname.
If I remember correctly, I think Scott suggested at least one name: Potato Guinness. It’s gender neutral.
Well Sophie’s the most popular girl’s name in Ireland these days (well in 2009 the last year that the names have been released for) Grace is number 5. It’s kind of sad that there’s only one traditional Irish name in the top 10 (Aoife). Mary’s been relegated to 61 just 119 girls in the entire country. Growing up it seemed there were that many in my school. Abigal is a lovely name and more popular than Mary in the old country, if anyone asks it comes in at number 46.
Love her names, love you, love her!
Abigail Grace is a beautiful name! I’m FBI, born on Saint Patrick’s Day, and very grateful my mom ignored her parents and in-laws who all thought Patricia wss the only appropriate choice…Slainte!
Congratulations on your new baby girl! From a totally unbiased standpoint, Abigail is an absolutely lovely name. Perfect choice!